Cheapest Grocery Store in City of New York 2026: Real Price Data
Stop & Shop Wins on Featured Sale Items
Based on July 2026 price data from PriceHive, Stop & Shop offers the lowest price on 4 of the 6 featured products below in City of New York. H Mart and Lidl each lead on one item. Note: nearly every current best price shown is a temporary sale.
Key Price Comparisons
| Product | Lowest Price | Highest Price | Price Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Activia Yogurt | $2.99 (sale) at Stop & Shop | $8.69 (sale, reg $10.99) at Costco | 191% more |
| Chobani Greek Yogurt | $3.99 (sale) at Stop & Shop | $10 (sale) at Lidl | 151% more |
| General Mills Cereal | $1.99 (sale) at Stop & Shop | $3.79 (sale) at Lidl | 90% more |
Closer Look at Other Products
Organic Valley Whole Milk is cheapest at H Mart ($3.99 sale) compared to $5.79 (also on sale) at Stop & Shop. For Ground Beef Patties, Stop & Shop ($10.49 sale) beats ALDI's $14.29 (also on sale) by 36% — both are priced per package with weight not specified, so per-lb comparison isn't possible. Lidl also has a better deal on Tomatoes On The Vine ($1.49/lb sale) vs Stop & Shop's $1.88/lb (also on sale).
Bottom Line
Stop & Shop offers the most savings across these 6 featured products, but H Mart is worth checking for milk and other staples — across all NYC data, H Mart actually leads on the most product categories overall. Several of the deals highlighted here are temporary sales, so verify current prices before shopping.
Help Us Track Prices in City of New York
This analysis is based on community-submitted prices from 13 stores across City of New York.
Submit current prices for these products via PriceHive to help us keep this data up to date. Your contribution helps shoppers save money in 2026 and beyond.