King Soopers Marketplace vs Safeway in Colorado Springs: Which Is Actually Cheaper? (2026 Price Data)
We pulled the latest community-submitted prices from King Soopers Marketplace and Safeway in Colorado Springs to see which chain has the better deals right now. The results are surprisingly even — each store wins on different categories, and several head-to-head matchups are not the apples-to-apples fight they appear at first glance.
Overall Verdict: It Depends on Your List
Based on prices submitted through June 26, 2026, neither store is a clean winner. King Soopers Marketplace tends to win on block cheese, pantry staples, and produce, while Safeway currently has the more aggressive sale prices on meat and yogurt. Read on for the actual numbers behind each category.
Category-by-Category Breakdown
Here is what shoppers actually submitted. A few rows compare different products or package sizes — we have called those out so you can judge the deal yourself.
| Category | King Soopers Marketplace | Safeway | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Greek Yogurt | Oikos triple zero blended Greek yogurt vanilla: $4.99 (sale, regular $5.29) for 5.3 oz | Chobani. Zero sugar Greek yogurt strawberry: $3.49 (sale) for 907 g | Different brands and pack sizes — the Chobani tub is roughly six times the size of the Oikos cup, so per-kg Safeway is dramatically cheaper. |
| Mini Cheese (Babybel) | Babybel Original Mini Cheese: $9.99 (sale, regular $12.79) for 12.7 oz | CHEESE mini: $5.49 (sale) | Same brand, but the Safeway listing does not specify pack size — cannot compare per piece. |
| Boneless Skinless Chicken Breasts | Boneless Skinless Chicken Breasts: $10.00 for a 1.31 lb pack (~$7.63/lb) | Natural Boneless Skinless Chicken Breasts: $1.99/lb (sale) | Safeway is clearly cheaper per pound this week. |
| Butter | Land o lakes butter: $4.99 for 16 oz | Land o lakes butter: $3.49 (sale) | Same product at both stores — Safeway has it on sale. |
| Potatoes | Baker size russet potatoes: $3.99 per package | Gold potatoes: $4.99 (sale) | Different varieties (russet vs gold), so this is a rough comparison, but King Soopers is cheaper on the bag. |
| Mozzarella | Kroger, mozzarella finely shredded cheese: $2.33 (sale, regular $2.49) for 8 oz | Galbani, precious, fresh mozzarella cheese: $8.99 (sale) for 226 g | Different formats — shredded for cooking vs fresh ball — not interchangeable for most recipes. |
| Cheddar | Medium Cheddar Cheese Block: $2.33 (sale, regular $2.49) for 8 oz | Henning's, Cheddar Cheese, Chipotle: $6.99 (sale) for 369 g | Plain medium cheddar vs a flavored specialty cheddar — different products. |
| Peanut Butter | Jif Natural Peanut Butter - Creamy: $3.29 for 16 oz | Organic peanut butter spread: $3.99 (sale) for 510 g | Standard natural vs organic — King Soopers is cheaper on the bottle. |
Where King Soopers Marketplace Shines
Block cheese is a clear win — an 8 oz block of Medium Cheddar Cheese Block rings up at just $2.33 on sale at King Soopers, and the Kroger, mozzarella finely shredded cheese is the same $2.33 for 8 oz. For pantry staples, Jif Natural Peanut Butter - Creamy at $3.29 beats Safeway's $3.99 organic peanut butter. The Baker size russet potatoes at $3.99 also come in under Safeway's $4.99 gold potatoes, though the varieties are different.
Where Safeway Wins
Safeway's sale flyer is the better choice for meat and yogurt right now. Natural Boneless Skinless Chicken Breasts are marked down to $1.99/lb, well under King Soopers' ~$7.63/lb on a 1.31 lb pack. The 907 g tub of Chobani. Zero sugar Greek yogurt strawberry at $3.49 is also exceptional value compared with single-serve cups at either store. Even on butter, the same Land o lakes butter sold at both stores is $1.50 less at Safeway on sale.
Bottom Line
For block cheese, peanut butter, and a sack of potatoes, King Soopers Marketplace has the edge. For chicken, butter, and big tubs of Greek yogurt this week, Safeway's sale prices come out ahead. Sales rotate weekly, so the smartest play is to check current flyers before committing your whole list to one store.
Help Us Track Prices in Colorado Springs
This analysis is based on community-submitted prices from 12 stores across 2 chains in Colorado Springs.
Prices change weekly. Help us keep this data accurate for your neighborhood. Submit your latest receipts and price photos to PriceHive to update our Colorado Springs database.