Kroger vs Safeway in Scottdale: Which Is Actually Cheaper? (2026 Price Data)
Based on data from May 21, 2026, Safeway is the more affordable option in Scottdale compared to Kroger. Out of 16 shared product types we tracked, Safeway offered lower prices in 10 categories, while Kroger was cheaper in only 6.
Overall Price Comparison
The gap between the two stores is clear. When comparing the cheapest option in each shared product category, Safeway consistently undercuts Kroger. There were no ties where prices were within 5% of each other. If you are shopping strictly for the lowest shelf price on these common goods, Safeway is the statistical winner on the majority of categories.
Key Price Differences
Below is a breakdown of specific items where the price difference is most noticeable. Note that several of these lower prices are temporary sales, and side-by-side rows may compare different brands or package sizes — per-unit math matters when the sizes do not match.
| Category | Kroger | Safeway |
|---|---|---|
| Greek Yogurt (150 g) | Chobani Greek Yogurt: $2.99 (sale) | Chobani Greek Yogurt: $0.89 (sale) |
| 80% Lean Ground Beef | Ground Beef 80% Lean: $5.99 / 16 oz (sale) | 80% Lean Fresh Ground Beef: $2.97 / lb (sale) |
| Boneless Skinless Chicken Breast | Perdue Fit & Easy Chicken Breasts: $2.74 / lb (sale) | All Natural Boneless Skinless Chicken Breast: $1.77 / lb (sale) |
| Butter | Unsalted Sweet Butter Sticks: $4.49 / 16 oz (sale, reg $4.99) | Butter quarters: $2.47 (sale) |
| Roma Tomatoes | Fresh Roma Tomato: $1.99 / lb | Roma tomatoes: $1.69 / lb (sale) |
| Sliced Cheese | Pepper Jack Cheese Sliced: $2.49 / 6 oz | Sliced Cheese: $3.49 (sale) |
| Cheddar Cheese | Sharp Cheddar Cheese Block: $2.49 / 8 oz | Cheddar Jack Tillamook Cheese: $5.49 (sale) |
| Russet Potatoes | Russet potatoes: $3.19 / 5 lb ($0.64/lb) | Russet potatoes: $0.99 / lb (sale) |
The cleanest like-for-like comparison is the Chobani Greek Yogurt, which is the same 150 g product at both stores — Safeway's sale price comes in at roughly 70% below Kroger's.
Looking at Eggs and Dairy
Eggs are an area where Kroger pulls ahead on per-egg cost. At Kroger, Eggland's Best Organic Large Brown Eggs are $4.69 for a 10-pack, and the Grade A extra large white eggs 18-pack runs $1.99 — about $0.11 per egg. At Safeway, the cheapest carton is Large cage-free eggs at $1.49 on sale (680 g package), while Free Range Large Grade A Brown Eggs are $5.47 on sale for a 12-pack.
On yogurt, the picture flips — the identical Chobani Greek Yogurt 150 g tub is $2.99 on sale at Kroger versus $0.89 on sale at Safeway.
Bottom Line
If you are filling your cart with dairy, butter, chicken, or ground beef, Safeway currently offers better value on the majority of items. However, keep an eye on the tags; many of Safeway's lowest prices, such as the $0.89 Chobani yogurt and $1.49 cage-free eggs, are marked as sales and may not last. If eggs and bag-quantity potatoes are your priority, Kroger may still be the better trip.
Help Us Track Prices in Scottdale
This analysis is based on community-submitted prices from shoppers across 3 Scottdale grocery stores.
Prices change weekly. Help us keep our data accurate for your neighborhood. If you spot a price change or a new deal at your local store, submit it via PriceHive.app.